by Adam Hartzell

Many film festivals seek to start a conversation amongst cinephiles and the wider community in which the films are screened, and to do that they need space. And the lobbies of many film festival venues are often antithetical to discussion. They become cramped spaces of rugby-like scrums of people trying to queue for a seat, the bathroom, a snack, a friend they see in the distance, and, when the film ends, a convenient exit. Once outdoors, the scrum continues, pushed out into the cramped sidewalk where one has to join the strolling pedestrians often obstructed by those in queue for the next film. This year's San Francisco Silent Film Festival provided an opportunity to see how an addition of public space, The Castro Commons, could enhance or detract from the typical experience at the festival.
The Silent Film Festival takes place at the Castro Theatre partly because said theatre was built in the time of silent films and it is one of the few theaters in San Francisco able to project silent films properly. Equally important, the Castro Theatre has a foundation from which to build upon of regular theater-goers attuned to the importance of silent films. The Castro Theatre is half a block away from an awkward five-point intersection. And since the Castro is quite a scene at all times during the day and night, attracting tourists and locals to the queer-friendly bars, restaurants, and shops, this already awkward intersection is made more complicated by the heavy foot traffic.
Continued reading The San Francisco Silent Film Festival and The Castro Commons: The filmgoing experience....
Comments (2)
Comments on this Entry:
(Dennis James on
Jul 22, 2010 12:36 PM)
The blogger talks about THE IRON HORSE: "One of the topics of our conversation was Dennis James' insistence of announcing the presence of Chinese railworkers - as David Kiehn noted in the program, some of whom were actually played by Paiute Indians - with a dadadada dutdut dum dum dummmmmm twiddling of the Wurlizter ivories. Those accusing me of political correctness may argue James was in-sync with the time period, but the existence of 'original scores' for films is much in debate by scholars. Local organ-players often improvised, so pursuit of a 'pure experience' is often a moot point. Plus, in some ways James' choice of melody represents, I argued, a laziness, a musical cliché, and I would hope that future compositions would be more creative rather than fall into Looney Tunes-ish musical stereotypes. "
Sad that no one announced at the screening that I was playing the actual original musical score composed and compiled for the film by Erno Rapee for its original release in the Twenties . . . and essentially all I did was transcribe it at sight from orchestra to organ attempting to retain the instrumental characteristics of the original. I played the Castro showing from the conductor's score of THE IRON HORSE. . . and the choices of types of music, matters of cliche, creativity and the like were ALL Rapee's. My job, recreating the exact job of the silent film era musicians, was simply to play it.
Dennis James - Silent Film Concerts
(Adam Hartzell on
Jul 22, 2010 4:18 PM)
Dennis,
Thank you for taking the time to clarify that you were working from an un-improvised score that was released with the film, seeking not to add any of your own embellishments. Reading that, I'll definitely scratch the 'laziness' from my piece and call that a failure in judgment regarding word choice on my part. So apologies for that. And, yes, the context would be a helpful inclusion to prep the audience.
There is a benefit to trying to 'recreate' the original experience, yet, as scholars of the silent era have been excavating, the 'original' experience wasn't consistent from venue to venue as a silent film traveled, particularly, the aural experience. Yet when there are ‘official’ score releases, the musical cliché that accompanies and announces Chinese characters to Western audiences can be placed as historical curiosities along with the archaic racial language I mention in films like THE FLYING ACE. So staying true to the original score can have its intellectual benefits as much as they make some in the audience cringe.
Still, there's also a benefit to commissioning new scores or adjusted scores (or allowing for improvisation) during the film to either enhance or bring new meaning to these films. And based on what we hear in this original score, it is interesting to consider how emotions/actions/characters are announced in scores from the past and the benefit for allowing you and other talented performers more leeway to improvise from the original score as happened during the silent film era as well.
Regards,
Adam Hartzell